The 2025 NFL season is well underway, and with it comes the excitement of the rookie class. This year’s rookie report card evaluates how the first-year players have fared through the first quarter of the season.
Evaluating the Rookies
Grading rookies in their debut season isn’t an easy task. With expectations soaring high, the grading criteria demand accountability.
Only the players who meet performance benchmarks will earn A’s and B’s. Let’s dive into this year’s standout talents and their shortcomings.
Ashton Jeanty — Grade B
Ashton Jeanty has made a strong entrance in the league, currently ranking ninth in rushing yards with 282. He averages 13.9 fantasy points per game, sharing a similar average to Saquon Barkley.
His first weeks were slow, but a breakout in Week 4 established him as a force to reckon with. Jeanty’s performance includes three touchdowns against Chicago, showcasing his potential.
Omarion Hampton — Grade B
Omarion Hampton’s path has mirrored Jeanty’s in terms of early struggles. However, a sudden elevation in gameplay followed Najee Harris’ injury, allowing Hampton to shine as a primary back.
With an impressive average of 14.3 fantasy points per game, he caught at least five passes in the last two games. Hampton’s chances are looking bright ahead.
TreVeyon Henderson — Grade C
TreVeyon Henderson has faced challenges, sitting low on the rankings at RB35 with just 30.9 fantasy points. His numbers failed to impress, particularly in rushing.
However, he displays promise in the receiving department. Despite his quiet start, Henderson’s potential still shines through.
RJ Harvey — Grade C
RJ Harvey has also struggled to transition effectively, currently sharing the workload with J.K. Dobbins. His average points per game closely mirror Henderson’s performance.
Despite a few flashes, Harvey has yet to establish himself as a consistent fantasy play. He remains on the radar, but needs more opportunities moving forward.
Tetairoa McMillan — Grade C+
Tetairoa McMillan has shown some promise, though lacks touchdowns. His vast talent remains underutilized in Carolina’s struggling offense.
With injury concerns and inconsistent quarterback play, McMillan’s ability to deliver high scores may be hampered. An upward trajectory is crucial for his potential to shine.
Travis Hunter — Grade D
Travis Hunter is currently having a disappointing season considering his draft position at No. 2 overall. Averaging only 4.6 fantasy points, he struggles with split responsibilities on both sides of the ball.
The inconsistency of the Jaguars offense further burdens his production. A turnaround is needed for Hunter to justify his high draft value.
Emeka Egbuka — Grade A+
Emeka Egbuka is the shining star of the rookie class. Averaging 15.5 fantasy points per game, he ranks among the best at WR7.
His consistent performance amidst team injuries has made him a top target. Egbuka has proven to be a value pick, turning heads in the first quarter.
Matthew Golden — Grade D
Matthew Golden has not met expectations despite entering with high draft capital. Averaging only 5.3 fantasy points, he has struggled to claim a significant role in the Packers’ offense.
His speed is evident, but production has not followed suit. Investors in Golden should remain patient as he seeks the right opportunities.
Tyler Warren — Grade A
Tyler Warren is an exception in the rookie tight end landscape. Averaging over 10 fantasy points per game, he’s proving to be a reliable starter.
Warren has developed quickly in his role, providing unique athleticism and versatility. His growth is promising for the Colts’ offensive future.
Quinshon Judkins — Grade A
Quinshon Judkins missed the start of the season but upon his return, has thrived as Cleveland’s lead back. Averaging 14.7 fantasy points over three games, he’s displayed incredible capabilities.
Judkins is quickly establishing himself as a key player within the Browns’ offense, showcasing both speed and power.
Insights from the First Quarter
The first quarter of the season has highlighted the ups and downs for rookies. With injuries impacting several teams, some rookies have had the chance to step up, while others have struggled behind established players.
Overall, this rookie class offers a mixed review with diamonds hidden among the rough. As the season progresses, their performance is likely to evolve.
Looking forward, the focus will shift to whether these young athletes can maintain their trajectory or find a way to rebound from disappointing starts. Major adjustments will be necessary to ensure success.